Mon 12 Mar 2007
In the annals of Western warfare, many names play on the tip of the tongue: Alexander. Hannibal. Napoleon. Wellington. Lee. Patton.
One that certainly deserves to be among them is that of Leonidas, one-time king of ancient Sparta. His is a tale that needs little romanticizing; under invasion by the mighty Persian empire, Leonidas and a force of 300 picked Spartan Hoplites, along with a few thousand other brave Greeks from various of her city-states, marched north to the coast and a narrow mountain pass referred to in local vernacular as “The Hot Gates”. There, they met a Persian host estimated by modern historians at somewhere between 250,000 to 400,000 men - and held them for three days, until the treachery of a fellow Greek proved their undoing.
Three days. Outnumbered at least 50 to 1.
While many of the Greek forces chose retreat when scouts informed them of Persian encroachment around and to the rear of their forces via a hidden “goat path”, the Spartans, along with a handful of Thespians, chose to remain, likely to cover the retreat of the remainder of the Greek forces. To a man, the Spartans and their king died, yet not in vain: The Persian war machine was ground to a stop, giving the main Greek land forces time to assemble and march. Persia, ultimately defeated at land and sea, was forced to retreat, abandoning its conquest of Greece. Greece would go on to lend many elements of art and philosophy to the Roman empire which, of course, would begin the evolution of what we know today as “Western Culture”.
(You can find a good Wikipedia page on the battle here.)
This epic moment in time is handled reverently by Frank Miller and the rest of the cast and crew of “300″.
The tale is, of course, classically Miller. It is outsized, yet boiled down to simpler elements that a modern moviegoing audience can easily relate to. He creates a toweringly heroic hero in Leonidas, a decadent and nearly androgynous villain in Xerxes (the “God-King” of Persia), and then washes the movie in blood.
Certainly, many elements of fable are injected into the plot, not the least of which are a giant rhinocerous-as-siege-weapon, a grotesquely deformed hunchback (Ephialtes, the historical betrayer of the Greek forces), and Immortals who appear to be something other than human underneath their cold bronze masks. As I said, the movie is outsized and classically Miller-esque. Historical purists are bound, perhaps, for disappointment.
For the rest of us, the film is gorgeous, compelling and inspiring: Gerard Butler, as Leonidas, gives us a hero we can love, who reminds us that life is not all Blackberries, lattes and TiVo. The themes at play in the movie would have, at a time in civilization, pass for the norm: Freedom is not free; sacrifice of one’s life is the highest form of nobility; decadence is defeated by discipline. Freedom is the forte of good, tyranny the embodiment of evil. Glory in war, for those who fight in a just cause. Fighting not the fights you can win, but the fights that need fighting.
They are old values, and I daresay that it’s not a bad thing that each generation of young men in this country be reminded of them from time to time.
These messages are not subtly rendered; on the contrary, they’ll be in your face from the moment the screen begins rolling the the end credits, and any viewer with the comprehension of a particularly dense child can’t help but miss them. Yet, if you’re so inclined, all of Miller’s artistic license with particulars won’t take away form the song the film will sing to your soul, as it calls to something older inside each of us - that part of us that drove Leonidas and 300 Spartans to their death and glory 2,500 years ago, and which drove America’s “Greatest Generation” into suffering, death and ultimate victory against Nazism a mere 66 years ago. You will, truly, find yourself moved.
Unless, of course, you’re inclined to look at any war as unjustified, and a militarist philosophy as barbaric, illogical and unbefitting the modern, rational age. If this describes you, 300 will just be another hokey war story meant to rile teenage boys into the nationalist militarism that you detest. Casual cuts at homosexuality probably don’t help, either.
You can find a longer review at Protein Wisdom which is definetely worth the read. Predictably, much of the extrme-left of the blogosphere is in a lather to ridicule or denounce the film - some pundits even going so far as to openly wonder if the Bush Administration is somehow behind the funding for the film. While I will admit that, as a propaganda piece, this would rank as Goebbels-esque (particulary given the timing, when support for the War on Terror is flagging badly), the fact that Miller’s “300″ graphic novel (upon which the film is based nearly frame-for-frame) was released during the Clinton Administration should (but won’t) put this sort of nonsensical speculation to rest.
And by the way, go see the goddamned movie. I have half a mind to go back tonight, myself.
9 Responses to “ “300″ ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

March 16th, 2007 at 2:25 pm
I haven’t seen it yet, though I definitely intend to. It certainly does seem to be getting many different reactions. Just to show a couple of the different ones I’ve seen…
http://hub.ou.edu/articles/article.php?item_id=1851205885§ion_id=57469591
ā30 minutes in, and Iām fully erect. This might warrant a four-star rating.ā
compared to:
http://www.thestar.com/article/190493
“This moral universe would have appeared as bizarre to ancient Greeks as it does to modern historians.”
I can only have so much fun watching the commentary — clearly, I have to go see this for myself.
March 18th, 2007 at 6:34 am
Strange. It flagged your comment for moderation.
I would say that part of a person’s enjoyment of the film would hinge on how strongly nationalistic / patriotic / militaristic their leanings are. While it’s certainly possible to enjoy the movie if you’re a pacifist multiculturalist, finding value in the movie’s themes of sacrifice, valor and resistance to tyranny raise it from a good graphic novel adaptation to one of the premier movies of recent memory.
Think Sin City-meets-Braveheart-meets-Gladiator and you won’t be too far off.
March 20th, 2007 at 10:06 am
Gotcha. I guess I’m just odd, as a patriotic multiculturalist that believes in a strong yet responsible/accountable military.
(though you and I might mean slightly different things by “multiculturalist” — or maybe not)
I suspect that I will find the movie to kick ass in any case. Braveheart’s lack of accuracy had little to do with its ability to kick ass, and few people are better at writing things that kick ass than Frank Miller.
March 20th, 2007 at 11:07 am
Well, when I talk about “multiculturalists”, I refer to people who feel that no one culture has any value or moral authority as compared to any other.
As someone who would admit to being a very strong “American Exceptionalist”, I walked out of the theater ready to go enlist in the Marine Corps.
March 20th, 2007 at 11:13 pm
Ah. See, I think there is more than one kind of multiculturalist. (unsurprising, I guess)
One could believe that no one culture could possibly have such moral (or other) superiority. In my opinion that is a bizarre and cowardly thing to think, but there are certainly people out there that fit the description.
Then there are those that think that no one culture has _intrinsic_ superiority of any kind, and that you actually have to look at the details of any given comparison in order to decide who is “better” in any particular fashion — moral or otherwise. Such a person might believe that their own nation comes out on top in most such comparisons, but if they do then this belief is not out of blind nationalism but rather out of reasonable awareness and consideration of the available facts.
Both of these people might be considered multiculturalists, but I would argue that they are very different viewpoints.
March 22nd, 2007 at 3:32 pm
Damn it, I saw another preview for 300 last night. This movie looks so badass — I’m really pissed that I haven’t gotten off my pansy multiculturalist ass to see it yet.
March 22nd, 2007 at 3:36 pm
I blame the queerbait ponytail.
March 22nd, 2007 at 8:33 pm
Typical fascist profiling, of course.
Those ponytailed weirdos can’t be trusted.
March 23rd, 2007 at 4:23 pm
Yeah, well. I got a rep to maintain, here.